MMD BLOG


CATEGORY:

PARENTING + KIDS

MOTHERHOOD ADVICE | YOU GET THE KID YOU GET AND YOU DON'T THROW A FIT

 Modern Mommy Doc


PUBLICATION DATE:

December 22, 2017

MOTHERHOOD ADVICE | YOU GET THE KID YOU GET AND YOU DON'T THROW A FIT

 Modern Mommy Doc

CATEGORY: PARENTING + KIDS

"You get the kid you get and you don't throw a fit." It's a piece of motherhood advice we've all heard before.


- It's when our babies are colicky and we wonder why they won't behave like all the "normal" infants.

- When our toddlers keep throwing fits, despite our best attempts.

- When our teenagers break our hearts with their seemingly careless choices.

- It's a lesson that's especially poignant when patience runs thin.


Last week, one of my patients told me how her husband stormed out of their house the night before. Not for an extended period of time, just for a few minutes while he cooled off.


Her daughter was throwing a fit, something that has become a regular occurrence for the past week between the hours of 4 to 7 PM. Why? She spent the weekend at her grandparents' house, on a sleepover while mommy and daddy had a much-needed local getaway. The little girl had a great time: she went blueberry picking, went to the pet store and was treated to fast food restaurants she would otherwise never frequent. But she also didn't get enough sleep, was overstimulated and was generally exhausted by the time she got home (By the way, if you want help on temper tantrums, sign up for our free guide here).


This week, they have been playing catch-up as they focus on a steady regimen of consistent meals, consistent bedtimes and plenty of outdoor play. It's not that her grandparents did anything wrong, it's just that their sensitive child is a finally-tuned machine. It will take a week of that kind of consistency before she will get back to herself, she told me.


That's what really bugs her husband, she said. The fact their daughter can't just roll with the punches like everyone else. He wants her to be flexible. He wants her to be able to enjoy life without constantly paying attention to all of her high-maintenance needs and wants her to "grow out of this already!”


I feel for that mom. I understand that very same struggle. It happens at my house and it's a common one for so many parents.


I thought about where the friction really is in their family. It comes down to two things: an acceptance of temperament and a patience for perceived weaknesses.



Temperament


In the same way it's impossible to fit a square into a round hole of equal size, it's also impossible to parent our kids well if we don’t understand and accept their temperaments.


Temperament is a set of in-born traits that organize a child’s approach to the world (check out the Child Development Institute for more). Some of our kids are difficult. Some of them are really easy. There are some kids that are super challenging when they’re not quite rested or fed but they seem to take direction perfectly at other times, making it tricky to figure out what the heck to do with them. (The Center for Parenting Education has more information on the concept of temperament and guidance on determining your child’s). If we rely on a set parenting style alone, and don’t adjust it for the temperament of our individual children, we’re setting ourselves up for failure.


That's a hard lesson for a lot of parents to learn. This is especially true when they themselves had parents who had a really strict, no-nonsense, “just do it the way I say or else,” authoritarian parenting style. They might have a lot of pressure to do the same for their kids. Or maybe they just aren’t prepared because their first child was a breeze and their second takes a lot more work. When they look at that second kid, there can be a lot of behaviors that seem like weaknesses.



Perceived Weaknesses


I challenged my patient’s mom to think about her daughter’s idiosyncrasies as potential strengths versus weaknesses. Was there another way to frame the attributes that really challenged her?


For example, one of my daughter’s best qualities is her imagination and her creativity. She spent 30 minutes last week dancing outside by herself - tap shoes fastened, tutu fluffed, prancing around in the garden. Then, she decided she wanted to have a lemonade stand and give free ice-cold drinks to EVERY SINGLE neighbor on our street.


She's also super in-tune to other people’s emotions. If I've had a hard day or I look sad, she picks up on it immediately. If her friends get hurt or need attention, she's the first one to jump in and offer help.


At the right moment, those can be her biggest strengths. I’m in total awe of her.


But her emotional sensitivity and crazy, wild creativity also make her more highly sensitive in a more negative way. It sets her up for anxiety and fear when it comes to what might happen at the dentist (“The Berenstein Bears book said they might pull my tooth out! I can’t go!”), with the doctor (“Remember last time when we went to there and sister cried for 80 hours? I think that might happen again.”) or on a playdate if things don’t go her way (“I really wanted to play with that and Anna took my doll and now she’ll never give it back because she likes it a whole lot and she doesn’t have one so she’ll probably want to take it,” she sobs). It leads to a lot of meltdowns and whining. The worst part? They're all usually really articulate, well-constructed whine and cry sessions.


At those moments, if I’m being honest, I am not focused on her strengths. All I see are weaknesses. But the truth is, if she didn’t have that extreme sensitivity, the things that sometimes drive her dad and I to our wit’s end, she wouldn't have the other amazing parts about her. It’s up to us as parents to work on coaching her so that she can eventually (we’re talking months to years, not days), learn to control the emotions that come washing over her and use her logical brain to make more of her decisions, allowing her to be on an even keel more often.


I want to be real about the sense of loss that all of us face with our kids at some time or another.


The realization that our kids are not perfect. The reality that sometimes we are really embarrassed by the way they act. The fact that sometimes we wonder WHAT THE WHAT we are doing so wrong to make our kids have the “weaknesses” they do.


Of course, sometimes things really are out of hand and you need extra help from your pediatrician or a mental health professional. All situations are not created equal and having an outside point of view can be necessary. But, for those all too common, “I thought we just went over this with you yesterday so why are you acting like this again?” moments with our kids, remember that each of our children is a unique being, that their temperament is individual and that they’re trying their best to work with their strengths and “weaknesses,” just like you.

Mama: Stop the Burnout!

Free 5-Day Program

START NOW
By asterbenc July 29, 2025
About the Episode: In this eye-opening episode of the Modern Mommy Doc podcast, Dr. Whitney Casares sits down with child sleep experts Dr. Andrea Roth and Dr. Allison Shale—two clinical psychologists and co-authors of The Essential Guide to Children’s Sleep: A Tired Caregiver’s Workbook for Every Age and Stage (written with Dr. Shelby Harris) . Together, they break down the myths, shame, and unrealistic expectations that surround slee p training and offer compassionate, evidence-based advice that actually meets parents where they are. This episode is your permission slip to stop blaming yourself, throw out the cookie-cutter advice, and start working with your child’s unique temperament, challenges, and developmental stage—whether that means defiant toddlers, anxious middle-schoolers, or non-sleeping newborns. About Our Guests: Dr. Andrea Roth and Dr. Allison Shale are licensed clinical psychologists and moms who specialize in child and adolescent mental health. Together with co-author Dr. Shelby Harris, they created The Essential Guide to Children’s Sleep to give exhausted parents the tools to support their kids’ sleep with confidence, flexibility, and empathy. Their approach is grounded in science—and shaped by real-life parenting. Follow them on Instagram: @essentialkidssleep Key Takeaways: Why this sleep book is different It’s written by clinical psychologists, not influencers—and it combines science, flexibility, and real-world parenting experience. How your child’s daytime behavior impacts nighttime sleep From anxious kids to defiant or ADHD children, the team explains why your child’s personality and emotional regulation during the day matters more than you think at bedtime. The truth about sleep “milestones” You’ll learn why your two-week-old shouldn’t be sleeping through the night, why “wake windows” are often misused, and why transitioning to a toddler bed before age 3 might be setting everyone up to fail. The importance of timing and readiness Parents don’t have to sleep train when they’re already overwhelmed. These experts offer a refreshing take on how to assess if now is the right time—and how to set up for success. What works for toddlers (and what doesn’t) You’ll hear how techniques like the “break method” and “camping out” can be adapted based on your child’s age and developmental stage. How to support anxious or defiant older kids at bedtime The language we use matters. For anxious kids, it's all about reducing pressure and focusing on rest. For defiant or ADHD kids, clear expectations and behavior-based plans are key. The shame-free approach every tired caregiver needs Sleep doesn’t have to be a battleground—or a place for guilt. These authors bring compassion and practicality to every step of the process. 📩 Subscribe to The Modern Mommy Doc Podcast for more episodes on parenting with confidence and clarity. L eave a review using the hashtag #ModernMommyDoc.
By asterbenc July 22, 2025
YOU get to choose.
By Dr. Whitney July 16, 2025
Looking for the perfect backpack? Look no further.
By Your Working Mom Life June 12, 2025
Trust me: you can trust yourself.
By Your Motherhood Journey June 5, 2025
Is shame holding you back from all the relationships you wish you had?

Welcome! Get the information you need to win at parenting without losing yourself.

LEARN MORE

Doing it All is Finally Here!


Wish your partner would do more to lessen your mental load?


Want to make self-care a priority but not sure how to?


SIGN UP FOR SUSTAINABLE SELF-CARE. IT'S FREE. CLICK HERE



FRESH

ON THE PODCAST


By asterbenc July 29, 2025
About the Episode: In this eye-opening episode of the Modern Mommy Doc podcast, Dr. Whitney Casares sits down with child sleep experts Dr. Andrea Roth and Dr. Allison Shale—two clinical psychologists and co-authors of The Essential Guide to Children’s Sleep: A Tired Caregiver’s Workbook for Every Age and Stage (written with Dr. Shelby Harris) . Together, they break down the myths, shame, and unrealistic expectations that surround slee p training and offer compassionate, evidence-based advice that actually meets parents where they are. This episode is your permission slip to stop blaming yourself, throw out the cookie-cutter advice, and start working with your child’s unique temperament, challenges, and developmental stage—whether that means defiant toddlers, anxious middle-schoolers, or non-sleeping newborns. About Our Guests: Dr. Andrea Roth and Dr. Allison Shale are licensed clinical psychologists and moms who specialize in child and adolescent mental health. Together with co-author Dr. Shelby Harris, they created The Essential Guide to Children’s Sleep to give exhausted parents the tools to support their kids’ sleep with confidence, flexibility, and empathy. Their approach is grounded in science—and shaped by real-life parenting. Follow them on Instagram: @essentialkidssleep Key Takeaways: Why this sleep book is different It’s written by clinical psychologists, not influencers—and it combines science, flexibility, and real-world parenting experience. How your child’s daytime behavior impacts nighttime sleep From anxious kids to defiant or ADHD children, the team explains why your child’s personality and emotional regulation during the day matters more than you think at bedtime. The truth about sleep “milestones” You’ll learn why your two-week-old shouldn’t be sleeping through the night, why “wake windows” are often misused, and why transitioning to a toddler bed before age 3 might be setting everyone up to fail. The importance of timing and readiness Parents don’t have to sleep train when they’re already overwhelmed. These experts offer a refreshing take on how to assess if now is the right time—and how to set up for success. What works for toddlers (and what doesn’t) You’ll hear how techniques like the “break method” and “camping out” can be adapted based on your child’s age and developmental stage. How to support anxious or defiant older kids at bedtime The language we use matters. For anxious kids, it's all about reducing pressure and focusing on rest. For defiant or ADHD kids, clear expectations and behavior-based plans are key. The shame-free approach every tired caregiver needs Sleep doesn’t have to be a battleground—or a place for guilt. These authors bring compassion and practicality to every step of the process. 📩 Subscribe to The Modern Mommy Doc Podcast for more episodes on parenting with confidence and clarity. L eave a review using the hashtag #ModernMommyDoc.
By asterbenc July 22, 2025
YOU get to choose.
By Your Working Mom Life June 12, 2025
Trust me: you can trust yourself.